Many Happy Returns to conductor James Loughran, Barbirolli’s successor at the Hallé, 89 today. Jun 30, 2020 | News, Ramblings | 9 comments A few years ago I met James Loughran at a lunchtime function and we had a pleasant chat, and he also bought me a beer. 9 Comments Monica McCabe on June 30, 2020 at 2:19 pm Again, birthday greetings to James Loughran. He was great fun, and a wonderful friend to John, both performing and recording his works. He was not well treated by the Halle, at a time of a palace revolution there. We still exchange Christmas cards. Surprisingly, to me, he shares a birthday with my dear maternal grandmother, which will make it easy for me to remember. Obviously an auspicious day…. Reply PETER LONGSHAW on June 30, 2020 at 9:02 pm As well as the CHAGALL WINDOWS (see below) I loved your husband’s Hartmann Variations premiered by Maurice Handford (another conductor I adored but players thought badly of). The Halle programmed it for the last night of their proms as it is such a loveable piece. Reply John Boyden on June 30, 2020 at 3:29 pm I made a stack of recordings with Jimmie including all the Beethoven symphonies, a set that (annoyingly) never made it to CD. I always found him to be a delight. We had to use the Free Trade Hall, with its awkward platform, which was far from matching the Bridgewater Hall. Monica is right about the backstage tensions. Following on from Barbirolli, a living God in Manchester, cannot have been easy, yet I never saw him be anything but positive and keen to do his best by the composer. They were happy days for me and I hope for him. Many happy returns to you Jimmie Reply PETER LONGSHAW on June 30, 2020 at 8:57 pm thank you for those great LPs which I still cherish on cd. I remember the Eroica LP cleverly done with movements 2; 3; 4; 1 to avoid distortion. The Elgar symphonies are hugely undervalued and I love the Rachmaninov 2 still. Reply John Lill on June 30, 2020 at 7:57 pm Hearty Congratulations, dear Jimmie. I’ve been honoured by working with you as soloist for around 120 concerts since 1965. They have all been a joy to give and continually inspiring under your unique mastery. The Hallé Orchestra was lucky indeed that you immediately continued from Sir John Barbirolli for many years of packed concerts but I find it disgraceful that you are lacking in the praise you so deserve from the orchestra you so admirably developed. The many thousands of music lovers you created in your audiences speak for themselves. Your powers of architecture and orchestral balance are second to none and your infectious, warm personality is all but missing in today’s clinically correct but all too boring, overrated types. Very well done! I shower you with praise and rich admiration. You have enhanced my own career immeasurably. Reply PETER LONGSHAW on June 30, 2020 at 8:51 pm As a schoolboy the Halle were my heroes as was JL. The players do seem to have unkind words to say about him but he kept their profile high with that Brahms CFP cycle, especially. I remember the premiere of John McCabe’s CHAGALL WINDOWS with a documentary on ITV (those were the days!) and recorded by EMI. Later at a performance of the piece in Guildford under Charlie Groves (when we still had an orchestra) the composer kindly signed my programme from the premiere. His EMPEROR with John Lill was the finest I have heard. Of so many concerts I will mention one that I took my Latin teacher to: it began with a Havergal Brian symphony (whom JL championed), then Brendel played the 3rd Beethoven and during the Brahms 3 Brendel stood at the side circle to hear the performance, Clearly he rated JL. A fun concert was when he invited the second violin on the front desk (another Scots Jimmie) to play the Bruch Scottish Fantasy, still the only live one I have heard after 45 years. He brought the wonderful SCO he founded to the Halle Proms (2 weeks of real concerts then, not Harry Potter themes) with the last 3 Mozart symphonies in one concert. Was he the first to do this? He was a natural for the Last Night of the Proms (Boulez was never going to do it!) and introduced Auld Lang Syne. My first ever concert of thousands was Jimmy: the Hindemith Concert Music for Strings & Brass (a piece I adore but sounded strange when I was 15); VW concerto with Lady B and the EROICA. How I miss live concerts…the internet fodder does not work for me. Reply Monica McCabe on July 1, 2020 at 8:02 am Thank you, Peter Longshaw, for your kind comments, and warmest greetings to both John Lill and John Boyden. There was a certain music critic, now dead, long resident in the Manchester area, who seemed to be very antagonistic to both orchestra and conductor. His lacerating criticisms were often destructive rather than constructive, and came close to destabilising the orchestra – or so it seemed to me, as an outsider. Reply EDWARD CLARK on July 1, 2020 at 11:01 am Happy Birthday James. I collected your Brahms Symphony cycle with the Halle on CFP. They remain benchmark performances for me; entirely natural, unforced, lyrical and yet powerful as well. You got excellent playing from the Halle too. A truly great achievement along with a relatively few classics in my opinion. Reply Ates Orga on July 1, 2020 at 2:29 pm An EBU bicentenary Beethoven symphony cycle, which Robert Simpson produced for broadcasting with the LSO in 1970 – the orchestra slimmed down, with natural trumpets, no doublings, hard sticked timpani – stays firmly in the memory. The first time I recall having heard the scherzo of the Fifth in its five-section ur-form, ABABA. One wonders if the BBC kept these performances in their archives or destroyed them in the “interests” of space saving. If the former, then it would be good to have them resurrected and re-mastered. Here meanwhile is 51 minutes of birthday Brahms – the Second Concerto with John Lill and the Halle, 1982, producer John Boyden https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYFMem-ktAI Reply Submit a Comment Cancel replyYour email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *Comment Name * Email * Website Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.