Photo, BBC/Mark Allan

REVIEWED FROM LIVE RELAY ON BBC RADIO 3

Sunday, August 16, 2026

Royal Albert Hall, London

In days of yore this not-quite-seventy-minute programme could well have been just the first half of a Prom. Quality before quantity of course…

Anton Webern, having rejected numerous pieces, finally published his Opus One, the Passacaglia (1908), restless, febrile, as well as meticulously composed within an ancient form, subtly changing, well-captured by the RPO and Vasily Petrenko, if a little too hysterical too soon as the biggest climax is reached.

Together with Max Bruch’s G-minor Violin Concerto, Elgar’s Cello Concerto must be the most put-upon work in the repertoire in terms of box-office fodder, to its detriment. Pablo Ferrández is nevertheless an impressive cellist, and established himself immediately with gutsy attack, then overdoing the musing if with attractive tone, but dragging, and, however nimble, the second movement was a little on the quick side. Eloquence returned for the slow movement, if at slightly the wrong side of slowness, and the Finale found the soloist a bit thin of tone in the highest register, moving forward but wallowing again before the abrupt coda. Petrenko and the RPO were sympathetic to him, and if I’d bet that Ferrández would play Pablo Casals’s arrangement of ‘Song of the Birds’ as an encore (however touchingly) I would have walked off with a few quid. The Spanish connection.

At its 1960 premiere (Edinburgh Festival; Liverpool Philharmonic/John Pritchard) William Walton’s Second Symphony found some critics disappointed that he had not written another First Symphony; failing to note that, twenty-five years having elapsed, Walton had moved on to more-compact structures and leaner-sounding scoring, not forgetting a geographical change. Yet, as recordings by Szell, Previn, Brabbins, and others, demonstrate (while confirming the idiocy of some of those initial reports) that Walton Two is just as vibrant and colourful as his music from the 1920s and ‘thirties, or the successive scores for Olivier’s Shakespeare movie triptych. Stokowski took it to the LSO and a Royal Festival Hall performance by the Philharmonia and Leonard Slatkin (May 1995, alongside Elgar, Michael Berkeley and Britten) had a first movement of remarkable energy that audibly stunned the audience. This Symphony means business from the first bar, an exordium to listen, music with an ecstatic singing line and punchy rhythms developing apace, a little understated here, and broken into by Petrenko with the surprising introduction of a much slower tempo before regaining where they had been, ensemble not always pristine. The languorous and exotic middle movement was finely done (Walton now living on the Italian island of Ischia), so too the Variations of the ‘Passacaglia’ Finale, opened imposingly by sonorous brass, the commentaries fleeting if coming together for the jubilant coda, although that quality was lacking here, too cautiously paced.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00302zn

Somewhat different (tempo) to their HMV recording.