Photo, BBC/Andy Paradise
Live at the BBC Proms: the BBC Concert Orchestra and conductor Robert Ames celebrate prog rock with BBC Radio 6 Music presenter Stuart Maconie and special guests.
Presented by Elizabeth Alker live from the Royal Albert Hall, London.
Copland, arr Robert Ames: Fanfare for the Common Man
Ian Anderson arr Sam Gale: Living in the Past
Mike Ratledge, arr Gale: Out-Bloody-Rageous
Tony Banks, arr Adam Dennis: A Trick of the Tail; arr. Sam Gale: I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe); arr. Christian Balvig: Northern Lights(5 mins)
Justin Hayward, arr. Fiona Brice: Nights in White Satin
Peter Hammill, arr. Adam Dennis: Refugees
Yes, arr. CHAINES: And You and I – Close to the Edge – Siberian Khatru
Mike Oldfield: Tubular Bells, Part One (excerpts)
Keith Emerson, arr. Robert Ames: Karn Evil 9: 1st Impression, Part 2
Osibisa, arr. Christian Balvig: Komfo
Frank Zappa, arr. Christian Balvig: Peaches en Regali
Thijs van Leer, arr. Christian Balvig: Sylvia
King Crimson, arr. Fiona Brice: 21st Century Schizoid Man – I Talk to the Wind – Court of the Crimson King
Ian Anderson: Reasons for Waiting
Tony Banks, arr. Fiona Brice: Entangled; arr Sam Gale: On Reflection
The Incredible String Band, arr. Christian Balvig: Maker of Islands
Richard Wright, arr. Fiona Brice: Great Gig in the Sky
Rick Davies, arr. Christian Balvig: Crime of the Century
Greg Lake, adapted from Mussorgsky, arr. Robert Ames: The Great Gates of Kiev
Guy Garvey
Jane Weaver
Gruff Rhys
Carl Palmer, drums
Peter Hammill, vocals
“Prog rock exploded the tight boundaries of pop music, amplifying it with new symphonic scope, ambition and influences and creating spectacular visual and musical statements. The Proms celebrates this pioneering, British-driven movement in a concert celebrating classic tracks on an orchestral scale. Award-winning broadcaster and BBC Radio 6 Music host Stuart Maconie presents brand new orchestral arrangements of music by ELP, Genesis, Jethro Tull, Mike Oldfield, Renaissance and others.”
Didn’t like Gruff Rhys’ vocals on Living In The Past. He couldn’t seem to be able to cope with the timings. Not good at all.
Completely agree. He looked bewildered in all his performances. Not impressed that he couldn’t even use the autocue correctly!
It was a great disappointment even though I knew he would put his own take on how to perform. He really struggled with the timing of his delivery. It sounded badly under rehearsed and I wondered if he had he ever heard the Tull original.
So good though that Progressive Rock was highlighted.
Absolutely fantastic night of music. A massive thank you to everyone involved. I was buzzing, all the way home, from the Royal Albert Hall, to East Grinstead.
I felt, only listening to the Frank Zappa and King Crimson sections, that the complexity of the music was missed, there was little power and drive. In short it was mostly emasculated. In particular the subtlety of the music of both Zappa and Crimson was mushed into easy listening and the truly great bits were left out. I refer you to a former member of King Crimson’s comments on Ossie Osbornes version of Schizoid Man, “They left out all the hard bits”
Listened to the concert on R3 at home. After a good start with ELP’s reworking of Fanfare, Gruff Rhys really let the side down on Living in the Past – he seemed woefully under-prepared for the task (or hopelessly miscast) and showed no real familiarity or intuitive feel for the song. A little later Peter Hammill was his unique self on his song Refugees, which is all to the good. For me, the Yes and Crimson mashups worked well, and the wordless vocal on Great Gig in the Sky deserved the roar of approval that Vanessa Haynes got. Needless to say, the BBC Concert Orchestra acquitted themselves excellently on everything they did. Overall I thought the second half of the concert held together better than the first.
Listening to the concert on BBC Sounds.
IMHO, with my system with BBC monitor loudspeakers, Jane Weaver seemed to struggle with Northern Lights and Nights In White Satin
…and watching it on TV likewise. I thought her thin reedy voice didn’t hack it with Northern Lights, and was woefully mis-cast for NiWS.
Watched on TV, great, but having seen set list online, found and listened to “Living in the Past” – what an amateur and awful vocal! They should have invited Ian Anderson, who would have of course stole the show! A let -down for all Tull fans, sorry to say but all other vocal performances were good apart from Gruff Rhys really in my opinion
After watching on TV and noticing “Living in the Past” omitted from live running order, found it online from radio version and have to say I can understand why, the vocal was substandard and under-rehearsed – quite surprised , sounded under rehearsed, and a great pity for all Tull fans who hoped to see it anyway, otherwise a very good concert and good to see Carl Palmer and other guests.