Stimulated by knowing that the celebrated Hollywood String Quartet’s complete recordings (though not the one with Frank Sinatra) have just been issued as a box in Japan I returned to Testament’s 1990s’ CD coverage of these tapings, and opted for SBT 1031, which acted in 1993 as my discovery of HSQ’s superb collective musicianship when Stewart Brown, Testament founder, released a choice coupling of Schoenberg’s Verklärte Nacht (in its chamber original, later for string orchestra) and Schubert’s String Quintet. I was totally sold and now have all, certainly most, of Testament’s HSQ issues.
HSQ was formed in 1939 but its activities were soon on-hold due to World War II and the men enlisting, so from 1947 to 1961 the group made numerous much-praised releases. From 1950 (Schoenberg) and 1951 (Schubert) these versatile musicians, each with a Hollywood film-studio background – Felix Slatkin, Paul Shure, Paul Robyn & Eleanor Aller – are joined by viola-player Alvin Dinkin (he would later replace Robyn) and Kurt Reher (who also appears as Schubert’s second cellist) in touchstone accounts of these two works – suspense-filled in Schoenberg’s sextet, selfless yet full of personality in both pieces, intimate yet outgoing, dynamic in every sense, musically perceptive and satisfying, drawing the listener in to make the seventy years that have elapsed since these compelling renditions were set down seem like only yesterday.
As much as the Japanese set is tempting – there writes a collector! – I shall rest content with Testament’s HSQ reporting. After all, SBT 1031 enjoys Paul Baily’s expert transfers, Tully Potter’s illuminating booklet note, as well as Schoenberg’s own words on Transfigured Night, which graced Capitol’s first issue, cover illustrated, and Richard Dehmel’s in-German poem (with an English translation by Lionel Salter) that inspired the music.
Funny but I was playing the Ormandy/Minneapolis SO 1936 recording this morning and luxuriating in the warmth of the strings captured on the recorded sound probably a mile away from the reduction heard from the HSQ which I would like to hear some day,
I really don’t know which version of Verklarte Nacht I prefer, full strings or sextet. Edward’s recommendation makes me want to investigate the Minneapolis/Ormandy version, although the version by which I got to know the work as a schoolboy, Barenboim’s ECO version for EMI, also employed full strings, and gosh was it opulent. I would lock myself in my room while the other kids played football and play the LP grey in a spirit of self-regarding adolescent angst. Colin, keep up this super Archive Column. We vinyl junkies need something with which to retain our sanity in these parallel-universe times!
I shall do so Andrew, many thanks.