Originally posted on May 15
This latest recording of the ‘New World’ Symphony (making how many, I wonder, since Hamilton Harty and the Hallé in 1923) is immediately seductive in its gentleness. Greater dynamism finds the basses vivid, as throughout the performance, with much attention given to pizzicatos (don’t be alarmed that the channels are reversed, for Lahav Shani has these instruments positioned to the left because the violins are illuminatingly antiphonal). This freshly considered reading, with numerous subtleties of detail and articulation, and Shani’s flexibility of tempo is refreshing largely because he avoids mannerism and intervention to retain a sense of related progression, thus the flute-led third subject in the first-movement exposition (repeated) eases naturally, and the second-movement Largo emerges as seamless based on a poetic cor anglais solo intimately expressed, following which the Scherzo is dashing and incisive, and if the Trio is slower it is once again persuasive. The Finale swirls along like one of the composer’s Slavonic Dances, the curious cymbal ‘rub’ is well-managed and ideally clear, and the growth of the music to a resolute climax, jazzy payoff (Dvořák being prophetic) and a nicely-judged diminuendo continues Shani’s ability (aided by excellent playing and sound) to refresh the most-jaundiced ear in this ubiquitous work, whatever the diversion may be. Also included is Dutchman Johan Wagenaar’s Cyrano de Bergerac (Overture, 1905), ebullient, scenic and touchingly melodic music already done proud by Chailly and the Concertgebouw (Decca) and equally enjoyable from the near-neighbours in Rotterdam. Warner Classics 2685431458 is released on May 29.