Bit by bit the LSO and Sir Antonio are gathering a VW Symphony Cycle of the utmost distinction. Following Four and Six, Five and Nine make a thought-provoking coupling – the contemplative, spiritual Fifth, a radiant corollary to World War II, which some commentators suggested back then might be his final such work (he was already elderly), but, no, four more Symphonies, very different, with no lessening of imagination, and powerful communication, came along. The sacred Fifth is eloquent and mystic, beautifully played, especially nimble in the niftier-than-usual second movement, brought off with considerable attention to detail, and the succeeding ‘Romanza’ is quietly glorious, and transporting, if not without agitation, and the outer movements, ecstatically climaxed, steal the listener’s soul. Barbirolli and Boult of course in this music (especially a live performance from the latter, below), with Brabbins, Handley, Previn, and Slatkin, to make a formidable collective (and Spano, Telarc), as they do (except Barbirolli, no recording even if he conducted it) for the underrated Ninth, Boult twice, maybe/maybe not related to Hardy’s Tess of the d’Urbervilles, and/or Stonehenge, VW’s exit Symphony, with scoring that includes a flugelhorn and a trio of saxophones, conjures much that is suggestive and gripping, vividly projected here, certainly not by a composer going through the motions or repeating himself. Pappano finds shadows of mortality within invention and colours courtesy of a still-searching creator. LSO Live LSO0900 [SACD].
Categories
- Anderson's Archive (49)
- Articles (7)
- Audiophile (14)
- Back Catalogue Reviews (4)
- BBC Proms 2020 (38)
- BBC Proms 2021 (51)
- BBC Proms 2022 (96)
- BBC Proms 2023 (107)
- BBC Proms 2024 (102)
- BBC Proms 2025 (144)
- BBC Proms 2026 (122)
- Berio centenary – October 24, 2025 (5)
- Betsy Jolas centenary – born August 5, 1926 (5)
- Blomstedt memorabilia (56)
- Book Reviews (2)
- Boulez centenary – March 26, 2025 (21)
- Bruckner 200 (born September 4, 1824) (58)
- Charles Ives 150: born October 20, 1874 (6)
- Christmas 2025 [the twelve days, 24/12-4/1/2026, have passed, relevant posts now collected] (6)
- Christmas Collections 2021 … and into 2022 (6)
- Christmas Crackers 2020 and then for all seasons (4)
- Christmas Recommendations 2024 (4)
- Column Honoree Eugene Ormandy (4)
- Column Honoree Herbert Blomstedt (7)
- Column Honoree Leonard Slatkin (24)
- Column Honoree Michael Gielen (6)
- Column Honoree Pierre Boulez (1)
- Column Honoree Sergiu Celibidache (4)
- Column Honoree Sir Adrian Boult (3)
- Column Honorees Introduction (5)
- Comedy (92)
- Concert Reviews (992)
- Concert Soundbites (28)
- Digital-only Releases (3)
- Enescu Festival 2023 (34)
- Film Reviews (1)
- Guest Contributors (415)
- György Kurtág – 100 on February 19, 2026 (6)
- Hans Werner Henze centenary – born July 1, 1926 (9)
- Holst 150 (born September 21, 1874) (5)
- Insights (150)
- Johann Strauss II 200 (born October 25, 1825) (4)
- Light Music Gems (27)
- Morton Feldman centenary composer – born January 12, 1926 (7)
- Music That Time Forgot (22)
- News (6,990)
- Opera Reviews (45)
- Outstanding [category w.e.f. January 2021] (712)
- Ramblings (478)
- Ravel 150: born 1875 on March 7 (15)
- Record of the Month [category w.e.f. July 2021] (24)
- Recording Reviews (637)
- Recording Soundbites (28)
- Schoenberg 150 (born September 13, 1874) (9)
- Shostakovich – died fifty years ago, on August 9, 1975 (14)
- Sir Arthur Edward Drummond Bliss – died fifty years ago, on March 27, 1975 (6)
- Soundbites (2)
- Uncategorized (31)
- Unexpected (83)
- Videos (2,794)
- Vinyl (101)
- YouTube Collections – for when the sagging shelves can't take any more and titles are becoming trickier to find! [category w.e.f. August 1, 2024] (24)
You raise an interesting point about Barbirolli and VW 9. As is tolerably well-known, the Symphony was first performed in April 1958 under Sargent (odd programme – with Kodaly Concerto for Orchestra preceding it and Berlioz Harold n Italy in the second half). Barbirolli conducted four performances the following October with the Halle – and never conducted it again!