Post pinned until October 16 release date
Neither of these performances are new to Szell’s discography having previously appeared on the West Hill Radio Archives label, although both are new to me. Surprisingly, given he conducted Franck’s D-minor Symphony several times in New York alone (between February 28, 1948, and April 6, 1970, the year of his death), there is no commercial taping, Cleveland being the obvious place for such an undertaking, although CBS did record this work with Bernstein and Ormandy. This live version – December 6, 1953 – is wonderfully potent from the off, powerfully articulated, impassioned, yet also flexible and even tender. Only the Finale raises a doubt, somewhat rushed if not throughout, although the New York Philharmonic (as we now know it) remains superb, the last few minutes touchingly yielding and building to a blazing peroration. Sibelius’s Second was even more a regular in Szell’s programming. He made a celebrated Concertgebouw recording for Philips (now Decca) and there’s a much-admired account captured at a concert in Tokyo with his Clevelanders (1970). I recently described this opus as Sibelius’s weakest Symphony, which drew a surprised response from my good friend Rob Cowan. No weaknesses as conducted by Szell on January 18, 1953 – dramatic, expressive, the score seen whole if with leeway moments, thrilling in the Scherzo (with a poetic oboe-led Trio) and a glorious Finale. Once again the NYP is magnificent. Lani Spahr’s remastering is first-class (so too his informative booklet note) – no sonic discolouration due to over-zealous processing, rather clear and dynamic sound that does justice to the music-making and the famed (pre-refurb) Carnegie Hall acoustic. SOMM ARIADNE 5051 is released on October 16. Vol.2 awaited.
https://somm-recordings.com/.
The Sibelius is a real find.
It becomes one of a series of Sib 2 performances and I look forward to hearing it asap.
My box set celebrating the 75th anniversary of the Cleveland Orchestra states
Disc Three is comprised of two symphonies by Jean Sibelius, one recorded in 1946, soon after Szell first arrived in Cleveland, and one recorded in 1970, only two months before his death.
Ed this is the famous concert performance in Tokyo.
The 1946 recording is of Sibelius’s Third Symphony, and the special Monday night radio concert from which it is taken is among the few early Szell broadcasts that have survived.
Ed thank goodness!
It was one of the few times that Szell conducted Sibelius’s Third Symphony and the only time that the Cleveland Orchestra has performed this work.
Ed I wonder who chose to perform No 3? Szell or the orchestra?
Obviously a pursuit of Sibelius’s symphonies apart from No 2 was not a priority in any way while Szell was in charge.
We should be grateful that he so adored No 2.